The election is over and we’ve had our fill of listening to both sides complain about the lies told by the other side. And most of us realize that the complaints are valid in both directions. Yet most of the lies told by politicians are a matter of implication. Out and out whoppers are pretty easy to discern, but candidates and campaign ads often manage to imply untruths without actually saying them outright.
So when we turn to this week’s text, John 18:33-38a, and find an experienced politician of the ancient world conversing with Jesus, it’s no surprise that Pilate ends the interview with a candid acknowledgement of political reality in relationship to matters of truth. Pilate’s question rings down the ages as the cry of cynics and skeptics everywhere, “What is truth?”
My academic background as a philosopher answers Pilate’s question with various theories of truth. Truth is coherence. What is true is whatever is self-consistent, a system of beliefs that do not contradict each other. Or truth is pragmatic. Truth is whatever beliefs work to further one’s goals in life. Coherence and pragmatism may be ways to test for truth, but the very nature of truth is as Aristotle said, “To say of what is that it is, and of what is not that it is not, is true.” In other words, truth is correspondence with reality. It doesn’t matter how consistent or practical your beliefs are, if they do not connect with what is real.
Pilate failed to see that connection as he spoke with Jesus. He was concerned with a practical, political truth. His questions to Jesus show him concerned merely to ascertain whether Jesus was making the claim to be a king, an offense against Rome punishable as treason. In verse 34, Jesus confronted Pilate with whether he actually cared about the truth of the matter, “Do you ask this on your own, or did others tell you about me?”
The rest of the dialogue shows us Pilate distancing himself from any attempt to discern anything about the reality of who Jesus is. “I am not a Jew, am I?” he says, indicating that the truth about any claim Jesus has to be a king makes no practical difference to Pilate.
Jesus tried to talk to Pilate about a kingdom that would make a difference to him, a kingdom that was not and never would be one of the political chess pieces of the Roman empire. It is kingdom of those who acknowledge Jesus Himself as the bearer of truth and who listen to Him (verse 37). But in the end Pilate’s closing question in verse 38 shrugs off even truth as a matter of no practical importance.
We are in Pilate’s position whenever we begin to let practical concerns, whether political or personal, economic or social, take precedence our hold on the reality of Jesus Christ as our Lord and King. If we imagine that political practice justifies compromise of Jesus’ love for all people we become like Pilate. If in order to take care of ourselves we treat others in ways that take no account of Jesus’ command to love our neighbors, we are little Pilates. If we think that making a living or protecting our economic standing entitles us to ignore Jesus’ teaching on sacrifice and generosity, then like Pilate we have tossed the matter of truth into the wind.
If Jesus Christ is our truth, if we acknowledge Him as King and wish to be in His kingdom, then we will live out that truth in every dimension of life. Truth is not merely whatever works, but if we subscribe to the truth that is Jesus, His truth will be working out in us.